Making Your Own Broth Is Easy - Right?

Written by Alison Bell

I’m sure you’ve all been researching bone broth recipes, and it all seems pretty simple right? Bones, onions, celery, apple cider vinegar, garlic, salt, pepper, water, a slow cooker or large pot on the stove and 24 hours. How hard can this be?
I know it took me many failed experiments before reaching the perfect broth every time. I certainly didn’t achieve a golden brown clear elixir, with lovely wobbly jelly like consistency first time, or even first 10 times! I had brown murky muddy water, it was thin and it was so strong to taste it was undrinkable. It didn’t gel so did that mean there were no benefits? No wonder so many people stop making broth and say ewwww to a brothee if this is the end result of your hard work!
But don’t despair, here are some tips to help you with your home cooked broth.

chicken broth pot

1. Equipment

I started my journey (and have continued) using the stove top, both gas and electric. Gas will of course enable a little more temperature control, but does leave a naked flame that can make everyone nervous. Many feel more comfortable using a slow cooker. This will ensure your house is still standing when returning home from an outing or after going to bed. You won’t feel chained to the house simply to “watch” your broth. It really is a personal preference. There is a slight difference in the taste and quality of the broth using a gas cook top vs the slow cooker. Either way make sure your pot or stock pot has the lid on so the condensation will fall back into the pot and loss of broth fluid is minimal. If you are in the market for a new stock pot, look for pots made of stainless steel, and I recommend a deep pot with straight sides. A large pot will allow you to make double or triple the amount of stock at one time, which you can then freeze in portion sizes for later use. I for one prefer to cook a large batch of broth once, rather than many smaller batches.

2. Temperature

Slow and steady is essential for cooking broth. Controlling temperature is a key way to ensure a gelatinous broth and you cannot do that with many slow cookers. You want to maintain a super low temperature, and if you only see one bubble pop up to the surface every minute, that is fine, you do not need to turn the temperature up despite your instincts to do so. If the broth is boiling too vigorously, it will make the broth quite “dirty”. Excess heat will also destroy the collagen which is what creates the gelatin and that perfect jelly like consistency. If you are unsure, err on the side of a low temp rather than high.

3. Length of cooking time

Once you get to that perfect just below simmer temperature, the bones must sit in that liquid for a lengthy period of time. Chicken requires between 12 and 24 hours, while beef and lamb need 24-48 and even up to 72 hours. If this time is cut short, then it may not be enough time for the gelatin along with other nutrients to be extracted from the bones. 

4. Water levels

A major reason for a broth lacking that wobbly texture is the water to bone ratio. There is no need to focus on the number of bones in your pot, but rather the ratio of bones to water weight. If there is too much water and not enough bones, then the broth will remain a liquid. Of course the size the bones have been cut will have an impact on how high they are in the pot, but a general rule to follow is to have the water level just covering the bones. This generally means approximately 3kg bones to 4 litres water. It is best to err on the side of too many bones, as you can always dilute your broth at the end, but cannot add extra bones! 

5. Bone quality

Bone quality is essential when making broth. If a chicken carcass was previously cooked, what ingredients were used to stuff the chicken? Just remember they will contribute to the flavour of your broth and if something like lemon was used, it may make the broth bitter. Chicken carcasses generally don’t offer a lot of gelatin, however when combined with chicken’s feet and necks, the collagen content increases dramatically. Beef bones also need to be a combination of joint bones, marrow bones, ribs and neck bones to get the best results. It is also very important to use organic grass fed bones when possible, or the process can be rather futile as you will be absorbing any chemicals the animal has been exposed to. 


Lastly there are some extra questions that always pop up:

Should you roast your bones in the oven first?

This is optional. Browning the bones will certainly add more flavour to your broth and improve the colour, but it does add an extra step, and reduce the nutritional benefits of the bone broth. 

What do you do with all that fat on top of the broth?

The fat is arguably the most nutrient dense part of your broth and has absorbed all the minerals during cooking time. I you don’t like to drink an oily broth, skim the fat and keep it to use as a cooking fat. It has exceptional flavour and a nice high smoke point so is a much safer option than most oils.

What do I do with the meat and veg in my broth?

Keep them and eat them! They are full of nutrients and have been cooked in broth. The meat will be super tender and the veggies soft and squishy. It is even an option to blend this up to a puree for baby food! And pets just LOVE it.

Can you reuse bones? 

Large bones can definitely be re-used. It will make a weaker and slightly less nutritious broth, but certainly still packs some punch. Just be mindful that the bones need to go straight into a freezer as once they hit room temperature, cooked soft bones become a nasty bacterial breeding ground within seconds.

Can I use veggie scraps in my broth?

Definitely make use of veggie scraps. Make use of the bottoms of carrots, the head and tails of your onion, the base of celery.


I hope I have helped shed some light on the common issues when making your own bone broth, and helped you overcome some fears. If you have any questions don't hesitate to ask. The more broth we are all drinking the better!


When you are feeling time poor or just can't be bothered making your own, that is where Broth of Life comes to the rescue. A pantry essential

Beef BrothChicken BrothLamb Broth



Write a comment


I was making broth on the stove top and it was as I expected it to be. (Jelly like consistancy with layer of fat on top). But on the stove top I was cooking it for about 8 hours so I switched to a slow cooker so I could cook it for longer 24 hours – but the broth is watery with very little fat on top and I wonder if its just because there is no evaporation?? I thought the slow cooker would make a better quality broth but now I’m not quite sure.


After soaking in Apple cider Vinegar, discard?

Alison @ Broth of Life

Hi Carly,
That’s a great question and one I debated mentioning. I think it depends greatly on the size of your pot, the temperature that pot is at when you turn it off over night and the climate you live in. I have done this with my personal batches but would never do it with our professional line.
At home I have brought my pot to the boil and turned it off late at night just before going to bed (around 11pm). I’m an early riser so it was turned back on at 5am and the broth temp was still very hot to touch. I would leave it to your own discretion, but do be careful of the temperature dropping too low and the possibility of bacteria forming in your broth. Bacteria love cooked bones more than raw meat so it is a risk if the temperature drops to room temp.
If the pot has gone “off” overnight, you will most certainly know about it from the smell.


Great post. Just wondering if you can turn stove off at night and then continue to simmer the next day? As I’m worried about naked flame to. I use s slow cooker as well but like to do two big batches at a time.


Great post. Just wondering if you can turn stove off at night and then continue to simmer the next day? As I’m worried about naked flame to. I use s slow cooker as well but like to do two big batches at a time.

Alison @ Broth of Life

Loz – so sorry!!! Oops! 2-4 days is generally how long it will last. The fat layer definitely helps it last longer. I would never trust broth longer than a week.


Hi Alison.. Thank you for your reply. 2-4 days or weeks? I leave a thick fat layer on the top which solidifys in the fridge and seals in the broth. Will that make it last longer in the fridge?


Alison @ Broth of Life

Hi Loz,
I have found broth to last between 2 – 4 in the fridge. But you will know by the smell – trust me, when it’s off you will REALLY know about it.
As your broth freezes in the glass jar, it will expand, which may cause the glass to break. So make sure to not overfill the jar/battle and leave the lid off to allow room for expansion. I find it is often easier to just fill an ice cube tray with the broth, that way I can pull out serving sizes, or even just one or two cubes to cook with.


How long can stock/broth last in the fridge before it goes bad? Can you put glass bottles of broth in the freezer??


Alison @ Broth of Life

Hi Stacey,
If you are looking to just drink the broth, I suggest adding some spices at the time you are drinking it. For example some ginger and/or tumeric which are brilliant flavour additions with the bonus of being anti-inflammatories and atioxidants. Either add fresh slices into your cup, or sprinkle some in powdered form and stir in. If you are looking for something at cooking time, it is really up to your personal preference. Bay leaves are always popular, along with parsley. Rosemary is my personal favourite, but it really is up to your imagination! They all go well :)


Thanks for the tips! Defiantly answered a few questions that I had and now I think I know where I was going wrong! Chicken is defiantly preferred in our house. Do you have any tips on any herbs or spices that you recommend for the beef broths?

Alison @ Broth of Life

Hi Denise,
You can still buy portable cooktops and also induction single burners. If peace of mind is important, then perhaps a slow cooker is the best and most cost effective option? Or course the quantity you wish to make will also have an impact on which path you choose. Best of luck on your journey, I’d love to hear which option you choose and how you progress!


This was very interesting. Thanks.
I think i have my broths sussed although soon we are going to gas and i am a little worried. Im worried if the flame goes out the house will just fill up with gas while we sleep. Plus i wont want to leave the house. Im thinking of buying a small one ring powered cooker to put on the bench just for broths.
What do you think? Can you still buy these?

Write a comment